Predatory Journal Checker: Red-Flag Score and Journal Shortlist (Free)
Got a flattering email inviting you to publish in a journal you have never heard of? Answer 14 red-flag questions based on Think. Check. Submit. and published criteria for predatory publishing. Each flag is weighted, so you get a risk score with a plain explanation and the official lists to verify every answer. Then compare your ambitious, realistic and safe journals side by side and export the table.
For each question choose Yes (the red flag is present), Not sure or No. Press ⓘ to see why it matters and where to check.
- PriceFree, no login or sign-up needed
- Your dataProcessed in your browser, never uploaded
- Works onPhone, tablet or computer, any modern browser
- Made byDr. Muhammad Aammar Tufail, Codanics
- Published22 November 2026
- Last updated22 November 2026
📚 How to cite this tool
This tool is free. If it helped your thesis, paper, report or assignment, please cite it. It keeps the tools free and helps other students find them.
Tufail, M. A. (2026). Predatory journal checker: Red-flag score and journal shortlist [Online tool]. Codanics. Retrieved 22 November 2026, from https://codanics.com/tools/predatory-journal-checker/
In-text citation: (Tufail, 2026) · Narrative: Tufail (2026)
The access date is today’s date, filled in automatically. Author: Muhammad Aammar Tufail. Published 22 November 2026.
How to use the predatory journal checker
- Type the journal’s name and publisher. An example (an invitation email from “Journal X”) is loaded so you can see how the score works.
- Answer the 14 red-flag questions with Yes, Not sure or No. Press ⓘ on any question to see why it matters and exactly where to check.
- Read the risk score (0 to 100), the band (low, caution, high, very high) and the explanation of each flag you raised.
- Open the verification links (Scopus, Web of Science Master Journal List, DOAJ, COPE, Sherpa Romeo) and turn every “Not sure” into a Yes or No.
- Switch to Compare 3 journals, enter your ambitious, realistic and safe choices, and export the comparison table as CSV or Markdown.
What is a predatory journal?
A predatory journal charges authors to publish but skips real peer review and editorial checks. An international consensus published in Nature (Grudniewicz et al., 2019) defines predatory journals and publishers as “entities that prioritize self-interest at the expense of scholarship” and that are marked by false or misleading information, poor editorial and publishing practice, lack of transparency, and aggressive, indiscriminate soliciting. Papers published there are often ignored by examiners, hiring committees and other researchers, and they are hard to move to a proper journal later.
The 14 red flags and their weights
| Red flag | Weight | What to look for |
|---|---|---|
| Too-fast publication promise | 3 (serious) | “Publication in 7 days”, guaranteed acceptance |
| Fake or invented metrics | 3 (serious) | Look-alike “impact factors” not issued by Clarivate |
| Not indexed, or indexing unconfirmed | 3 (serious) | Missing from Scopus, Web of Science and DOAJ |
| COPE membership not verifiable | 2 (serious) | Logo on the site, but not on the COPE members list |
| Spam invitation | 2 | Flattering mass emails, often outside your field |
| Unclear APC | 2 | Fees hidden or revealed only after acceptance |
| No clear peer-review policy | 2 | No description of reviewers, type of review or timeline |
| Editorial board problems | 2 | Unverifiable or unrelated members |
| Poor recent articles | 2 | Low quality, off-topic, DOIs that do not resolve |
| Very broad scope | 1 | Medicine, engineering and social science in one journal |
| Poor website quality | 1 | Typos, broken links, copied text |
| No verifiable contact details | 1 | Free email address, no postal address |
| Misleading or copied title | 1 | Imitates a well-known journal’s name or website |
| Missing publishing policies | 1 | No ISSN, licence, archiving or retraction policy |
How the score works: a “Yes” adds the full weight, “Not sure” adds half, and the total is scaled to 0 to 100. Under 15 is low risk, 15 to 34 is caution, 35 to 59 is high and 60 or more is very high. Any serious flag answered “Yes” puts the result at high risk or above, whatever the total. The weights follow the criteria in Think. Check. Submit. and the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing (COPE, DOAJ, OASPA and WAME).
How to verify a journal in five steps
- Search the title and ISSN in Scopus Sources and the Web of Science Master Journal List. Use the website address listed there, not the one in an email.
- For open-access journals, check DOAJ, which lists fees, licences and the peer-review type.
- Confirm the publisher on the COPE members list, and check its open-access and self-archiving policies in Sherpa Romeo.
- Read two or three recent articles. Check that their DOIs resolve with the reference checker.
- Work through the Think. Check. Submit. checklist and ask your supervisor or librarian.
Build a shortlist: ambitious, realistic, safe
| Choice | Typical profile | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Ambitious | Q1 in your subject category, competitive | The best home if reviewers like it |
| 2. Realistic | Q1–Q2, very strong scope fit | The most likely home |
| 3. Safe | Q2–Q3, broader scope | A backup, so a rejection does not stop you |
Quartiles are set per subject category: a journal can be Q1 in one category and Q2 in another. Check the Scimago Journal Rank (SJR quartiles) or Clarivate’s Journal Citation Reports (Journal Impact Factor). Record the APC, the time to first decision, the acceptance rate and the AI policy too: these affect your time and budget as much as metrics do.
| Metric | Who publishes it | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Journal Impact Factor | Clarivate (JCR) | Average citations to the journal’s recent articles |
| CiteScore | Elsevier (Scopus) | Citations per document over four years |
| SJR and quartile | Scimago (Scopus data) | Prestige-weighted rank; Q1 is the top 25% of a category |
| h5-index | Google Scholar | Citation strength of articles from the last five years |
Tips
- Fit first, metrics second. A Q1 journal that does not publish work like yours will desk-reject you in days.
- Never reply to invitation emails. Go to the journal through the official lists instead.
- Watch for hijacked journals. Criminals clone real journals’ websites. Check the URL against the Scopus or Master Journal List record, or the Retraction Watch Hijacked Journal Checker.
- Indexing can end. Scopus and Web of Science remove (discontinue) journals that stop meeting their standards, so check the current status.
- Use your own references. The journals that publish the papers you cite are often your best shortlist.
Frequently asked questions
How can I tell if a journal is predatory?
Search for it yourself in Scopus, the Web of Science Master Journal List and (for open access) DOAJ. Then look for the classic red flags: spam invitations, promises of publication within days, invented impact factors, hidden fees, no clear peer-review policy and a fake editorial board. This checker scores those red flags for you.
Does this tool say whether a specific journal is predatory?
No. It scores the answers you give and shows where to verify each one. It never labels a named journal or publisher. Use the official lists and your supervisor’s advice for the final decision.
Is a journal safe if it is indexed in Google Scholar?
No. Google Scholar indexes almost anything that looks academic, including predatory journals. Indexing in Scopus, Web of Science or DOAJ means much more, because those databases review journals before including them.
What is a hijacked journal?
A fake website that copies a real, indexed journal’s name and ISSN to collect fees from authors. Always reach a journal through the website address listed in Scopus or the Master Journal List, and check the Retraction Watch Hijacked Journal Checker.
Are all open-access journals with fees predatory?
No. Many excellent journals charge article processing charges (APCs) to cover costs. The difference is transparency: legitimate journals state their fees up front, run real peer review and are listed in DOAJ, Scopus or Web of Science.
What should I do if I already published in a predatory journal?
Talk to your supervisor. Do not cite the paper as strong evidence. Some authors ask the journal to withdraw the paper so they can submit it elsewhere, but this is not always possible. Learn from it and verify every future journal first.
How do I choose an ambitious, a realistic and a safe journal?
Start from journals that publish work like yours (your own references help). Pick a top journal as your ambitious choice, a strong-fit journal one level down as the realistic choice, and a broader journal as the safe backup. Compare them in the shortlist tab.
Do I need to log in or create an account to use the predatory journal checker?
No. There is no login, no sign-up and no email required. Open the page and start using it straight away, for free, on any device.
How do I cite this tool in my thesis or paper?
Use the citation box on this page. In APA 7th edition: Tufail, M. A. (2026). Predatory journal checker: Red-flag score and journal shortlist [Online tool]. Codanics. Retrieved [date you used it], from https://codanics.com/tools/predatory-journal-checker/. BibTeX, RIS (EndNote, Mendeley, Zotero), MLA, Harvard, Chicago and Vancouver formats are also available.
Free guides and courses from Codanics
More free tools
See all free Codanics tools → · Codanics on YouTube · WhatsApp channel