Scientific writing

Pre-Submission Checklist: 52 Checks Before You Submit Your Paper (Free)

Before you press Submit, work through 52 checks in four groups: content (title, abstract and conclusions match, gap and aim, repeatable methods, statistics, figures, no overclaiming), format (word limits, structure, reference style, figure resolution), integrity (verified references; data, funding, conflict, ethics, CRediT and AI statements; similarity check; no duplicate submission) and files (cover letter, title page, anonymised manuscript, figures, supplements). Each item explains why it matters and links to the Codanics tool that helps you fix it.

✅ No login needed100% free52 checksPrintable reportYour data stays on your device
Pre-Submission Manuscript Checklist✅ Free · no login📚 Cite this tool
Your data never leaves your PC. Everything you enter stays on your own computer or phone, and anything saved is kept only in this browser. Nothing is uploaded, stored or seen by Codanics, and no login is needed.
  • PriceFree, no login or sign-up needed
  • Your dataProcessed in your browser, never uploaded
  • Works onPhone, tablet or computer, any modern browser
  • Made byDr. Muhammad Aammar Tufail, Codanics
  • Published22 November 2026
  • Last updated22 November 2026

📚 How to cite this tool

This tool is free. If it helped your thesis, paper, report or assignment, please cite it. It keeps the tools free and helps other students find them.

Citation · APA 7th edition

Tufail, M. A. (2026). Pre-submission manuscript checklist [Online tool]. Codanics. Retrieved 22 November 2026, from https://codanics.com/tools/pre-submission-checklist/

In-text citation: (Tufail, 2026) · Narrative: Tufail (2026)

The access date is today’s date, filled in automatically. Author: Muhammad Aammar Tufail. Published 22 November 2026.

🚀 Follow Codanics channel on WhatsApp for more updatesNew free tools, scholarships, PhD positions and research tips, straight to your phone. Free lessons on YouTube too.

How to use the pre-submission manuscript checklist

  1. Type your manuscript title and target journal. An example manuscript with some checks already ticked is loaded so you can see how it works.
  2. Work through the four groups: content, format, integrity and statements, and files. Tick each item when it is done.
  3. Press ⓘ Why on any item to see why it matters, and follow the 🛠 link to the Codanics tool that helps you fix it.
  4. Mark items that do not apply (for example trial registration) as N/A, and switch on Show only unchecked to focus on what is left.
  5. When the ring reaches 100%, print the report or download it as text and share it with your co-authors before you submit.

What to check before submitting a manuscript

Before you submit, check four things: the content tells one consistent story, the format follows the journal’s guide for authors, every integrity statement is in place, and every required file is ready. Many desk rejections come from avoidable problems: a poor fit with the journal, ignored author guidelines, missing statements, inconsistent numbers or an unconvincing cover letter. This checklist turns the guide for authors and good practice into 52 tickable items.

GroupItemsTypical problems it catches
Content17Abstract numbers that differ from the results, unclear gap, unrepeatable methods, missing effect sizes, uncited figures, overclaiming
Format11Over the word limit, wrong reference style, low-resolution figures, tables pasted as images
Integrity and statements14Unverified or retracted references; missing data, funding, conflict, ethics, CRediT or AI statements; unreviewed similarity report; duplicate submission
Files and submission10Generic cover letter, missing title page, manuscript not anonymised, missing checklist or supplements

Statements most journals require

StatementWhat it saysFree tool
Data availabilityWhere the data can be found (a repository and DOI is best)Statement generator
FundingFunders and grant numbers, or “no specific funding”Statement generator
Competing interestsFinancial and personal interests of every authorStatement generator
Ethics and consentCommittee name, approval number and consentStatement generator
Author contributionsEach author’s CRediT rolesCRediT statement generator
AI useWhich AI tools were used, and for whatCheck the journal’s AI policy

Authorship should follow the ICMJE recommendations (check it with the ICMJE authorship checker), contributions are described with CRediT, and integrity questions such as duplicate submission are covered by COPE guidance. Reporting guidelines for every study design are collected by the EQUATOR Network.

Tips for the final check

  • Read the guide for authors again, line by line, against your manuscript. Use the author guidelines checklist to record each requirement.
  • Check the numbers three ways: abstract, results text and tables must agree to the last decimal.
  • Open every reference. Run the list through the reference checker to catch fake, wrong and retracted citations.
  • Verify the journal one last time with the predatory journal checker, and never submit to two journals at once.
  • Look at the PDF proof the submission system builds: symbols, Greek letters and tables sometimes break in conversion.
Writing the cover letter? Use the journal cover letter builder. Every free writing tool and quiz is on the scientific writing tools page.
Scientific Writing MarathonLearn the full method, step by step, with a mentor. This tool comes from the Scientific Writing Marathon by Dr. Muhammad Aammar Tufail: a complete online course that takes you from a research question to a finished manuscript, review or thesis chapter, with daily lessons, live online classes and a writing task on your own paper. Recorded lectures stay on the LMS, so you can learn at your own pace.

Frequently asked questions

What should I check before submitting a manuscript to a journal?

That the title, abstract and conclusions match; the methods can be repeated; statistics, figures and tables are complete and cited; the format follows the guide for authors; references are verified; data, funding, conflict-of-interest, ethics, CRediT and AI statements are included; and the cover letter, title page and other files are ready. This checklist covers 52 such items.

Why are manuscripts desk rejected?

Common reasons are a poor fit with the journal’s scope, ignoring the author guidelines (length, structure, references), unclear novelty, weak methods, missing statements or ethics approval, and poor presentation. Most of these can be caught with a careful pre-submission check.

What files do I need for journal submission?

Usually the manuscript (anonymised for double-blind review), a title page, a cover letter, figures as separate high-resolution files, supplementary material, and any required checklist such as CONSORT or PRISMA. Some journals also ask for highlights or a graphical abstract.

Do I need an AI disclosure statement?

If you used generative AI tools for writing, editing, analysis or images, most publishers require you to disclose which tools you used and for what. AI tools cannot be listed as authors. Check your target journal’s policy.

What does N/A mean in this checklist?

Mark an item N/A when it does not apply to your paper, for example trial registration for a lab study, or a response to reviewers for a first submission. N/A items are removed from the progress count.

Are my ticks saved?

Yes, in this browser only. Nothing is uploaded. Print or download the report to keep a permanent record or share it with co-authors.

Do I need to log in or create an account to use the pre-submission manuscript checklist?

No. There is no login, no sign-up and no email required. Open the page and start using it straight away, for free, on any device.

How do I cite this tool in my thesis or paper?

Use the citation box on this page. In APA 7th edition: Tufail, M. A. (2026). Pre-submission manuscript checklist [Online tool]. Codanics. Retrieved [date you used it], from https://codanics.com/tools/pre-submission-checklist/. BibTeX, RIS (EndNote, Mendeley, Zotero), MLA, Harvard, Chicago and Vancouver formats are also available.

Free guides and courses from Codanics

More free tools

See all free Codanics tools → · Codanics on YouTube · WhatsApp channel

Made by Dr. Muhammad Aammar Tufail, Codanics. First published 22 November 2026, last updated 22 November 2026. Found a bug or have an idea for a new tool? Tell us on the WhatsApp channel or in the comments on YouTube. Results are for learning and planning; check important analyses with a statistician or your supervisor.