ICMJE Authorship Checker: Who Is an Author, Who Is Acknowledged (Free)
Who should be an author on your paper, and who belongs in the acknowledgements? Add every contributor, tick the four ICMJE criteria and their CRediT roles, and the checker classifies each person, flags gift, guest and ghost authorship, and writes a CRediT statement and an acknowledgements paragraph for you. It also gives you a checklist for the author-order conversation.
Add everyone who helped: authors, technicians, statisticians, writers, funders. Tick On the author list for the people currently named as authors.
ICMJE authorship criteria (summary)
The International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) recommends that an author meets all four criteria:
- Substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work, or to the acquisition, analysis or interpretation of data; and
- Drafting the work or revising it critically for important intellectual content; and
- Final approval of the version to be published; and
- Agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work, so that questions about the accuracy or integrity of any part are properly investigated and resolved.
- Anyone who meets criterion 1 should be given the chance to take part in drafting, revising and approving the manuscript.
- Contributors who do not meet all four criteria are acknowledged, with their permission.
- Funding, general supervision of a research group, administrative support, writing assistance, language editing and proofreading alone do not qualify someone for authorship.
- AI tools such as chatbots cannot be authors, because they cannot approve the work or be accountable for it.
Source: ICMJE, Defining the Role of Authors and Contributors. Many journals outside medicine follow the same principles.
Problem authorship
| Type | What it means |
|---|---|
| Gift | Someone is added who did not contribute substantially, as a favour or in return for a favour. |
| Guest (honorary) | A senior or well-known person is added because of their position, to make the paper look stronger, without meeting the criteria. |
| Ghost | Someone who meets the criteria, or who wrote a substantial part of the paper, is left off the author list and not acknowledged. |
The 14 CRediT roles
Definitions from CRediT, the Contributor Roles Taxonomy (ANSI/NISO Z39.104-2022), credit.niso.org.
- PriceFree, no login or sign-up needed
- Your dataProcessed in your browser, never uploaded
- Works onPhone, tablet or computer, any modern browser
- Made byDr. Muhammad Aammar Tufail, Codanics
- Published22 November 2026
- Last updated22 November 2026
📚 How to cite this tool
This tool is free. If it helped your thesis, paper, report or assignment, please cite it. It keeps the tools free and helps other students find them.
Tufail, M. A. (2026). ICMJE authorship checker: Author or acknowledgement [Online tool]. Codanics. Retrieved 22 November 2026, from https://codanics.com/tools/icmje-authorship-checker/
In-text citation: (Tufail, 2026) · Narrative: Tufail (2026)
The access date is today’s date, filled in automatically. Author: Muhammad Aammar Tufail. Published 22 November 2026.
How to use the icmje authorship checker
- Add every person who helped with the work, in the current author order, then everyone else (technicians, statisticians, writers, funders). A seven-person example is loaded first.
- For each person, tick On the author list if they are currently named as an author, and choose their position.
- Tick the ICMJE criteria each person meets and click their CRediT roles. Open ICMJE criteria and CRediT roles for the definitions.
- Read each person’s result: author, potential author or acknowledgement, plus any gift, guest or ghost authorship flags. Fix the problems with your co-authors.
- Copy the CRediT statement and the acknowledgements paragraph, work through the author-order checklist, and download the full report.
Who qualifies as an author?
Under the ICMJE recommendations, an author must meet all four criteria: a substantial contribution to the design, data or analysis; drafting or critically revising the manuscript; approving the final version; and agreeing to be accountable for the work. Anyone who meets fewer than four is thanked in the acknowledgements instead. The ICMJE recommendations were written for medical journals, but most journals in the life and social sciences, and the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), follow the same principles.
| ICMJE criterion | Examples | Matching CRediT roles |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Substantial contribution | Designed the study, collected or analysed data, interpreted results | Conceptualization, Methodology, Investigation, Formal analysis, Data curation, Software, Validation, Visualization |
| 2. Drafting or critical revision | Wrote sections, revised the argument, not just typos | Writing – original draft; Writing – review & editing |
| 3. Final approval | Read and approved the version submitted | (no CRediT role: confirm by email) |
| 4. Accountability | Can answer questions about any part of the work | (no CRediT role: agree in writing) |
Gift, guest and ghost authorship
| Problem | Typical example | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Gift authorship | A friend or colleague is added as a favour, or in exchange for adding you to their paper | Remove them, or acknowledge their real help |
| Guest (honorary) authorship | A head of department is added because of their position or because they provided lab space | Acknowledge them; providing resources, funding or general supervision alone does not qualify |
| Ghost authorship | A statistician who did the analysis and wrote the results, or a paid writer, is left out completely | Add them as an author if they meet the criteria; otherwise acknowledge them and disclose who paid for the writing |
COPE and most universities treat gift, guest and ghost authorship as research misconduct, alongside fabrication, falsification and plagiarism. Authorship gives credit, but it also gives responsibility: every author can be asked to answer for the whole paper.
How CRediT and ICMJE work together
ICMJE decides whether someone is an author; CRediT describes what each person did. CRediT is a list of 14 contributor roles, published as the ANSI/NISO standard Z39.104-2022 and used by Elsevier, PLOS, Cell Press, MDPI and many other publishers. This checker writes the CRediT statement only for people who meet all four ICMJE criteria; for more formats (lead, equal and supporting degrees, Word and JATS XML) use the CRediT author statement generator.
Agreeing the author order
- Talk early. Agree criteria and order when the project starts, write it down, and revisit it if roles change.
- First author usually did most of the work and wrote the first draft. Last author is often the senior or supervising author, but this varies between fields.
- Some fields use alphabetical order, for example mathematics and economics.
- Joint first authorship is possible; check how your journal marks equal contributions.
- Changing the author list after submission needs every author’s written agreement and the editor’s approval.
Frequently asked questions
What are the four ICMJE authorship criteria?
1. Substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work, or the acquisition, analysis or interpretation of data. 2. Drafting the work or revising it critically for important intellectual content. 3. Final approval of the version to be published. 4. Agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work. An author must meet all four.
Should my supervisor be an author?
Only if they meet all four criteria, for example by helping design the study, critically revising the manuscript, approving it and taking responsibility for it. General supervision of a research group alone does not qualify; in that case thank them in the acknowledgements.
What is the difference between gift, guest and ghost authorship?
Gift authorship adds someone who did not contribute, as a favour. Guest (honorary) authorship adds a senior person because of their position. Ghost authorship leaves out someone who meets the criteria or who wrote a substantial part of the paper. All three are research-integrity problems.
Who goes in the acknowledgements?
Anyone who helped but does not meet all four criteria: technicians, people who collected samples, statisticians who only advised, language editors, people who provided lab space or funding. Ask their permission before naming them.
Can a person with only CRediT roles like Funding acquisition be an author?
Not on that basis alone. ICMJE says acquisition of funding, general supervision and administrative support alone do not justify authorship. They also need to revise the manuscript, approve it and accept accountability.
How is the author order decided?
By agreement between the authors. In many fields the first author did most of the work and wrote the draft, and the last author is the senior or supervising author. The checker suggests an order from the CRediT roles as a starting point for that conversation.
Is my contributor list saved or uploaded?
It is saved only in this browser, so you can come back to it. Nothing is uploaded or seen by Codanics.
Do I need to log in or create an account to use the icmje authorship checker?
No. There is no login, no sign-up and no email required. Open the page and start using it straight away, for free, on any device.
How do I cite this tool in my thesis or paper?
Use the citation box on this page. In APA 7th edition: Tufail, M. A. (2026). ICMJE authorship checker: Author or acknowledgement [Online tool]. Codanics. Retrieved [date you used it], from https://codanics.com/tools/icmje-authorship-checker/. BibTeX, RIS (EndNote, Mendeley, Zotero), MLA, Harvard, Chicago and Vancouver formats are also available.
Free guides and courses from Codanics
More free tools
See all free Codanics tools → · Codanics on YouTube · WhatsApp channel