Peer Review Report Builder: Write a Clear, Fair Review (Free)
Asked to review a paper for the first time? Build your report in the structure editors expect: a 3–4 sentence summary, an overall assessment, major and minor comments, confidential comments to the editor and a recommendation. Guided checklists help you check novelty, methods, statistics, claims, presentation and ethics; the comment helper turns a vague remark into a specific, useful one; and the tone checker flags harsh or personal wording before you submit.
Problems that affect the conclusions: design, analysis, interpretation, missing data or controls.
Clarity, figures, tables, references and typos. Give line or page numbers.
Mark each point OK, Concern or N/A. For a concern, press + Major or + Minor to start a comment in your report.
Turn a vague comment into a specific one
A useful comment says what the issue is, where it is, why it matters and how to fix it.
Reviewer ethics: the essentials
- Confidentiality. The manuscript is a confidential document. Do not share it, discuss it or use its content before publication.
- No AI uploads. Do not paste or upload any part of the manuscript, or your report, into ChatGPT or other generative AI tools: this breaks confidentiality and may break the journal’s policy. Many publishers explicitly forbid it for reviewers. If you use a tool to polish your own wording, check the journal’s policy and say so.
- Competing interests. Decline, or tell the editor, if you have a personal, financial or professional conflict, or if you cannot be objective.
- Expertise and time. Accept only if the topic is within your expertise and you can meet the deadline. If you decline, suggest another reviewer if you can.
- Be fair and constructive. Judge the work, not the authors. No personal remarks, and do not ask authors to cite your own work unless it is genuinely needed.
- Raise concerns with the editor. Suspected plagiarism, fabrication, duplicate submission or ethics problems go in the confidential comments, not in the comments to the authors.
- No co-reviewing without permission. Ask the editor before involving a student or colleague, and name them.
Based on the COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers (Committee on Publication Ethics). Always follow the journal’s own reviewer instructions too.
- PriceFree, no login or sign-up needed
- Your dataProcessed in your browser, never uploaded
- Works onPhone, tablet or computer, any modern browser
- Made byDr. Muhammad Aammar Tufail, Codanics
- Published22 November 2026
- Last updated22 November 2026
📚 How to cite this tool
This tool is free. If it helped your thesis, paper, report or assignment, please cite it. It keeps the tools free and helps other students find them.
Tufail, M. A. (2026). Peer review report builder [Online tool]. Codanics. Retrieved 22 November 2026, from https://codanics.com/tools/peer-review-report-builder/
In-text citation: (Tufail, 2026) · Narrative: Tufail (2026)
The access date is today’s date, filled in automatically. Author: Muhammad Aammar Tufail. Published 22 November 2026.
How to use the peer review report builder
- Read the confidentiality reminder. Keep the manuscript on your own computer and never paste it into an AI tool.
- Open Checklists and mark each point on novelty, methods, statistics, results and claims, presentation, and ethics as OK, Concern or N/A. Press + Major or + Minor to turn a concern into a starter comment.
- In Report, write a 3–4 sentence summary and your overall assessment, then edit your major and minor comments. An example review is loaded so you can see the format.
- Use the Comment helper to rebuild vague comments as issue, location, why it matters and suggested fix.
- Fix anything the tone check and the consistency checks flag, choose your recommendation, and copy the comments to the authors and the confidential comments into the journal’s form.
How to write a peer review report
A good peer review report summarises the paper, judges whether its conclusions are supported, and lists specific, fixable problems, separated into major and minor comments, with a clear recommendation. Editors read many reports: a structured, polite and specific one helps them decide and helps the authors improve the paper.
| Section | What to write | Who sees it |
|---|---|---|
| Summary | The aim, methods and main findings in 3–4 sentences, in your own words | Authors and editor |
| Overall assessment | Main strengths, main weaknesses, and whether the conclusions follow from the data | Authors and editor |
| Major comments | Problems that affect the conclusions: design, analysis, interpretation, missing controls | Authors and editor |
| Minor comments | Clarity, figures, tables, references and typos, with line numbers | Authors and editor |
| Confidential comments | Conflicts, limits of your expertise, suspected plagiarism or data problems | Editor only |
| Recommendation | Accept, minor revision, major revision, reject and resubmit, or reject | Editor (usually in the form) |
Weak and strong comments
| Weak | Strong (issue, where, why, fix) |
|---|---|
| “The statistics are wrong.” | “In Table 2, the authors used t-tests to compare three groups. This inflates the chance of a false positive. I suggest that the authors re-analyse with one-way ANOVA and a post-hoc test, or justify the current choice.” |
| “The discussion overclaims.” | “In the last paragraph of the discussion, the authors state that the treatment ‘will improve food security’. The trial covered one district and two seasons, so I suggest limiting the claim to similar conditions.” |
| “The English is poor.” | “Some sentences in the methods are hard to follow (for example lines 88–95). Language editing would help readers.” |
What the recommendations mean
| Recommendation | Use it when |
|---|---|
| Accept | Ready as it is; rare on first submission |
| Minor revision | Small changes that do not affect the conclusions |
| Major revision | Important problems that the authors can fix, such as a re-analysis or missing details |
| Reject and resubmit | Promising, but needs new data or a new analysis before it can be judged again |
| Reject | Serious flaws that cannot be fixed, or outside the journal’s scope |
The editor makes the decision; your recommendation is advice. Make sure your comments match it: a list of serious problems with an “accept” recommendation confuses everyone.
Confidentiality and AI tools
A manuscript under review is confidential. The COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers ask reviewers to keep the content confidential, declare competing interests, review only within their expertise, be objective and constructive, and raise concerns about misconduct with the editor. Uploading a manuscript to ChatGPT or another AI tool shares it with a third party, and many publishers’ reviewer policies explicitly forbid it. This builder runs entirely in your browser: nothing you type is sent anywhere.
- Check the methods against the right reporting guideline from the EQUATOR Network (CONSORT, PRISMA, ARRIVE, STROBE and others), or use the free reporting checklist.
- Suspect a fake or retracted reference? Check it with the reference checker (references are public, unlike the manuscript).
- Track your reviews in your ORCID record or Web of Science reviewer profile.
Frequently asked questions
What should a peer review report include?
A short summary of the paper, an overall assessment of its strengths and weaknesses, numbered major comments (problems that affect the conclusions), numbered minor comments (clarity, figures, references), confidential comments to the editor and a recommendation.
What is the difference between major and minor comments?
Major comments are problems that affect whether the conclusions are valid, such as the design, the statistical analysis or overclaiming. Minor comments improve clarity and presentation: wording, labels, missing units, typos and references.
Can I use ChatGPT to help write a peer review?
Do not upload or paste the manuscript into ChatGPT or any other AI tool: it is confidential, and many publishers forbid it for reviewers. Write the review yourself; if you use a tool only to polish your own wording, check the journal’s policy and disclose it if required.
How long should a peer review report be?
Usually one to two pages. The length matters less than being specific: every comment should say what the issue is, where it is, why it matters and how to fix it.
What goes in the confidential comments to the editor?
Competing interests, the limits of your expertise, your recommendation if the form asks for it there, and any concern about plagiarism, duplicate publication, data fabrication or ethics. Do not repeat harsh criticism there that you would not say to the authors.
How do I keep my review polite?
Comment on the manuscript, not the authors, explain why each point matters and suggest a fix. Avoid words like sloppy, nonsense or obviously. The tone checker in this tool flags harsh and personal wording, and requests to cite your own work.
Is my review saved?
Only in this browser, so you can come back to it. Nothing is uploaded. Clear it with “Start a new review” when the review is submitted.
Do I need to log in or create an account to use the peer review report builder?
No. There is no login, no sign-up and no email required. Open the page and start using it straight away, for free, on any device.
How do I cite this tool in my thesis or paper?
Use the citation box on this page. In APA 7th edition: Tufail, M. A. (2026). Peer review report builder [Online tool]. Codanics. Retrieved [date you used it], from https://codanics.com/tools/peer-review-report-builder/. BibTeX, RIS (EndNote, Mendeley, Zotero), MLA, Harvard, Chicago and Vancouver formats are also available.
Free guides and courses from Codanics
More free tools
See all free Codanics tools → · Codanics on YouTube · WhatsApp channel