Scientific writing

Review Type Selector: Narrative, Scoping, Systematic, Umbrella or Meta-Analysis? (Free)

Answer seven quick questions about your question, the number of studies, your time and your team. You get the review type that fits: narrative, scoping, systematic, umbrella or a meta-analysis. You also see its reporting guideline (PRISMA 2020, PRISMA-ScR, PRIOR), where to register the protocol (PROSPERO for health outcomes, otherwise OSF), typical time and team size, the minimum number of reviewers and a starter title built from your own topic.

✅ No login needed100% free5 review typesPROSPERO or OSF adviceYour data stays on your device
Review Type Selector✅ Free · no login📚 Cite this tool
Your data never leaves your PC. Everything you enter stays on your own computer or phone, and anything saved is kept only in this browser. Nothing is uploaded, stored or seen by Codanics, and no login is needed.
Your topic (optional, for the starter title)
  • PriceFree, no login or sign-up needed
  • Your dataProcessed in your browser, never uploaded
  • Works onPhone, tablet or computer, any modern browser
  • Made byDr. Muhammad Aammar Tufail, Codanics
  • Published22 November 2026
  • Last updated22 November 2026

📚 How to cite this tool

This tool is free. If it helped your thesis, paper, report or assignment, please cite it. It keeps the tools free and helps other students find them.

Citation · APA 7th edition

Tufail, M. A. (2026). Review type selector: Choose narrative, scoping, systematic, umbrella review or meta-analysis [Online tool]. Codanics. Retrieved 22 November 2026, from https://codanics.com/tools/review-type-selector/

In-text citation: (Tufail, 2026) · Narrative: Tufail (2026)

The access date is today’s date, filled in automatically. Author: Muhammad Aammar Tufail. Published 22 November 2026.

🚀 Follow Codanics channel on WhatsApp for more updatesNew free tools, scholarships, PhD positions and research tips, straight to your phone. Free lessons on YouTube too.

How to use the review type selector

  1. Answer question 1: what does your review question ask? A recommendation appears straight away.
  2. Answer the other questions: how many studies you expect, whether outcomes can be pooled, whether reviews already exist, your time, your team and whether the outcome is health-related.
  3. Optionally type your population, intervention, comparison and outcome to get a starter title.
  4. Read the best fit: reporting guideline, where to register, typical time, team, minimum reviewers, appraisal and synthesis. Check the warnings.
  5. Edit the title, then copy or download your review plan and discuss it with your supervisor or co-reviewer.

Which type of review should you write?

The review type follows your question. To find out whether an intervention works, write a systematic review, and add a meta-analysis if the studies report outcomes you can pool. To map what research exists on a broad topic, write a scoping review. To compare what several systematic reviews already conclude, write an umbrella review. For a broad expert overview of a field or an idea, write a narrative review.

Review typeQuestionReporting guidelineRegister onTypical timeReviewers
NarrativeHow has thinking on X developed?None formal (SANRA as a check)Not needed1–3 months1+
ScopingWhat research exists on X?PRISMA-ScROSF (PROSPERO does not accept scoping reviews)3–6 months2+
SystematicDoes X improve Y?PRISMA 2020PROSPERO (health outcomes) or OSF6–12 months2+ independent
Meta-analysisHow big is the effect of X on Y?PRISMA 2020PROSPERO (health outcomes) or OSF6–18 months2+ and statistics
UmbrellaWhat do existing reviews conclude?PRIORPROSPERO (health outcomes) or OSF6–12 months2+

Times are typical and depend on the size of the topic and the team.

Guidelines, registries and methods handbooks

  • PRISMA 2020 is the reporting standard for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: a 27-item checklist and a flow diagram. Its extensions include PRISMA-ScR for scoping reviews, PRISMA-P for protocols and PRISMA-S for searches.
  • The Cochrane Handbook sets out the methods for systematic reviews of interventions, including independent screening and extraction by at least two people.
  • GRADE rates the certainty of evidence for each outcome as high, moderate, low or very low.
  • PROSPERO registers systematic reviews with a health-related outcome. It does not accept scoping reviews, and you should register before screening starts.
  • OSF Registries accepts protocols from any field, including scoping reviews and reviews in agriculture, environment or education.
  • More reporting guidelines are listed on the EQUATOR Network.
Reviews are not easier than primary research. Choose a review because a synthesis is really needed, check that one does not already exist, and never call a narrative review “systematic”.

Common mistakes

  • Not checking PROSPERO, OSF and the Cochrane Library for an existing or ongoing review.
  • Planning a meta-analysis with too few or too different studies.
  • Screening alone when the method needs two independent reviewers.
  • Registering the protocol after screening has started.
  • A title that does not name the design: end it with “a systematic review and meta-analysis” or “a scoping review”.
Next steps: sharpen the question with the PICO research question builder and the FINER checker, write the protocol with the review protocol builder, then draw your PRISMA flow diagram and pool the results with the meta-analysis calculator. Every tool is on the scientific writing tools page.
Scientific Writing MarathonLearn the full method, step by step, with a mentor. This tool comes from the Scientific Writing Marathon by Dr. Muhammad Aammar Tufail: a complete online course that takes you from a research question to a finished manuscript, review or thesis chapter, with daily lessons, live online classes and a writing task on your own paper. Recorded lectures stay on the LMS, so you can learn at your own pace.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a scoping review and a systematic review?

A systematic review answers a focused question, such as “Does X improve Y?”, and judges the quality of each study. A scoping review maps what research exists on a broader topic and where the gaps are, usually without judging quality. Systematic reviews follow PRISMA 2020; scoping reviews follow PRISMA-ScR.

Is a meta-analysis the same as a systematic review?

No. A meta-analysis is the statistical pooling of results from several studies. It is usually done inside a systematic review, when the included studies report outcomes that can be combined. A systematic review can also synthesise studies without a meta-analysis (using SWiM).

Can I register a scoping review on PROSPERO?

No. PROSPERO does not accept scoping reviews. Register the protocol on OSF Registries or publish it in a journal.

Where do I register a systematic review that is not about health?

PROSPERO only accepts reviews with a health-related outcome. For agriculture, environment, education or engineering, register the protocol on OSF Registries.

How many reviewers does a systematic review need?

At least two. The Cochrane Handbook recommends that two people screen studies, extract data and assess risk of bias independently, and resolve disagreements by discussion or with a third reviewer.

How many studies do I need for a meta-analysis?

Two studies can technically be pooled, but with fewer than about five comparable studies the pooled estimate and heterogeneity are imprecise. With few or very different studies, report a systematic review with narrative synthesis instead.

What is an umbrella review?

A review of systematic reviews (also called an overview of reviews). It compares what several reviews on the same question conclude, appraises them with AMSTAR 2, and is reported with the PRIOR guideline.

Do I need to log in or create an account to use the review type selector?

No. There is no login, no sign-up and no email required. Open the page and start using it straight away, for free, on any device.

How do I cite this tool in my thesis or paper?

Use the citation box on this page. In APA 7th edition: Tufail, M. A. (2026). Review type selector: Choose narrative, scoping, systematic, umbrella review or meta-analysis [Online tool]. Codanics. Retrieved [date you used it], from https://codanics.com/tools/review-type-selector/. BibTeX, RIS (EndNote, Mendeley, Zotero), MLA, Harvard, Chicago and Vancouver formats are also available.

Free guides and courses from Codanics

More free tools

See all free Codanics tools → · Codanics on YouTube · WhatsApp channel

Made by Dr. Muhammad Aammar Tufail, Codanics. First published 22 November 2026, last updated 22 November 2026. Found a bug or have an idea for a new tool? Tell us on the WhatsApp channel or in the comments on YouTube. Results are for learning and planning; check important analyses with a statistician or your supervisor.